Cran-Raspberry Spindrift Sourdough (with Pistachios)

This loaf is the kind of bread that makes weekday dinners feel special and weekend breakfasts feel like a tiny celebration. It’s bright from cranberry + raspberry Spindrift, lightly spiced with cinnamon and cardamom, and studded with chewy dried cranberries and crunchy pistachios. The crumb is slightly enriched with butter and a touch of maple, but it’s still a real sourdough — not a cake in disguise. It’s approachable: you don’t need fancy techniques, only a bit of patience (and the payoff is a loaf that tastes like autumn in every slice). Great with cheese, turkey, or just warmed and smeared with butter.

💛 Support the Journey - I'm so glad you're here! If you enjoy what I'm doing, support me by clicking the product links in the recipe ingredients and instructions or below the recipe. I earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you). It helps keep this site ad-free! Or, visit the Support me page.

---

Jump to recipe

---

Jump to prompt (to see how this recipe was created using ChatGPT)

---

Jump to comments

---

Recipe

Servings: 8 (large slices)

Calories per serving (estimate): ≈ 398 kcal

Total time: 12–18 hours (Active time ≈ 1 hr 40 min; Inactive time ≈ 10.5–16 hours — includes autolyse, bulk rest, and overnight cold proof)

Cran-Raspberry Spindrift Sourdough (with Pistachios)

Bright, fruity, lightly spiced, dried cranberries + pistachios

Makes 1 large loaf (about 1.2–1.3 kg)

Ingredients

• 600 g (4 ½ cups) bread flour

• ½ cup active sourdough starter (100% hydration; about the texture of thick pancake batter)

• 1 cup Cranberry-Raspberry Spindrift (seasonal at Costco, but this works too)

• ⅔ cup water

• 1 tablespoon maple syrup

• 2 tablespoons softened unsalted butter

• 2 teaspoons fine salt

• 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon

• ¼ teaspoon ground cardamom (or mace)

Mix-ins

• ¾ cup dried cranberries

• ½ cup chopped pistachios (use untoasted if they’re already crunchy)

Finish (optional)

• 1 tablespoon browned butter, for brushing

Instructions

1. Prep starter & cranberries. Feed your starter 4–6 hours before mixing so it’s bubbly and domed. Put the dried cranberries in a small bowl and cover with ¼ cup of the Spindrift (taken from the 1 cup). Let soak 20–40 minutes. Drain and reserve the soaking liquid.

2. Autolyse (mix flour + liquids). In a large bowl, combine the 600 g (4 ½ cups) bread flour, cinnamon, and cardamom. Add ⅔ cup water plus all the Spindrift except the ¼ cup used to soak the cranberries. Also add the saved cranberry soaking liquid so the total Spindrift going into the dough equals 1 cup. Mix until no dry flour remains. Cover and rest 40–60 minutes.

3. Add starter, salt, syrup. After autolyse, add ½ cup active starter, 2 teaspoons salt, and 1 tablespoon maple syrup. Mix until everything is incorporated.

4. Add butter. Add 2 tablespoons softened butter in small pieces and fold/squish it into the dough until absorbed. The dough will feel softer and slightly tacky.

5. Bulk fermentation with folds. Over the next 2 hours, perform 3–4 sets of stretch-and-folds every 30 minutes (you can do coil folds or S-folds). During the second fold, gently incorporate the drained cranberries and chopped pistachios so they distribute without smashing.

6. Finish bulk. Stop bulk when the dough is puffy and has risen ~20–40% (not doubled). This usually takes 2–3 hours depending on room temperature. Note: Spindrift acidity/sugars often speed fermentation; don’t wait for a full double.

7. Pre-shape & bench rest. Turn dough onto a lightly floured surface, gently pre-shape into a round and rest 20–30 minutes uncovered or lightly covered.

8. Final shape. Shape into a boule and place seam-up in a floured banneton or bowl lined with a well-floured towel.

9. Cold retard (overnight proof). Cover and refrigerate 8–14 hours. This helps control proof and deepens flavor.

10. Preheat oven. Preheat oven to 480°F (250°C) with a Dutch oven inside for 45 minutes.

11. Bake. Invert dough onto parchment, score, and place in the hot Dutch oven. Bake covered 18 minutes at 460°F (240°C). Uncover, reduce oven to 430°F (220°C), and bake 18–25 minutes more until the crust is deep golden brown.

12. Finish. Brush the hot loaf with 1 tablespoon browned butter if desired. Cool at least 1.5–2 hours before slicing (important — hot loaf will gum otherwise).

Detailed nutrition (per serving — 1 of 8 slices) — estimated

Calories: ≈ 398 kcal

Carbohydrates: ≈ 72 g

Protein: ≈ 9.8 g

Fat: ≈ 7.3 g

Fiber: ≈ 3.4 g

Key micronutrients (approximate, food-based highlights):

• Iron & B vitamins (thiamin, niacin, folate): from the bread flour — support energy metabolism.

• Potassium & Magnesium: from pistachios — help electrolyte balance and muscle function.

• Vitamin B6 & Copper: pistachios are a good source — support nervous system and antioxidant enzymes.

• Antioxidants (polyphenols): dried cranberries and pistachios contain polyphenols that support general oxidative balance.

• Small vitamin C contribution from cranberry flavoring/fruit solids (minimal in dried cranberries but present).

Health notes:

• This is an energy-dense, real-food loaf — good for fueling activity or for family meals. The pistachios add heart-healthy monounsaturated fats, plant protein, and micronutrients; cranberries add flavor and antioxidant interest. If you’re watching sodium, trim the salt by ¼ tsp. If you need fewer calories per slice, cut the loaf into more than 8 slices or freeze slices for later.

Estimate method & caveat: Nutrition values above are calculated from the recipe ingredients and are estimates (rounded). They assume the listed ingredient weights and that the starter contributes minimal extra flour beyond what’s listed. If you want a lab-grade analysis or values per a specific brand of flour, I can produce a more precise table using the brand data.

Storage & freshness tips

• Room temp (short term): Store whole loaf in a paper bag inside a bread bag or loosely wrapped in a kitchen towel for 1–2 days. Keeps crust crisp and crumb moist.

• Longer (fridge is not ideal): Refrigeration speeds staling; only refrigerate if your home is very humid — then slice and toast before serving.

• Freeze: Slice and freeze in an airtight bag for up to 3 months. Toast or warm slices straight from frozen.

• Recrisping: To refresh the crust, spritz with a little water and bake at 350°F (175°C) for 6–8 minutes, or toast slices.

My picks:

Lodge 6 Quart Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven with Lid – Dual Handles – Oven Safe up to 500° F

50 Pcs Disposable Banneton Liner,Non-Stick Bread Proofing

NeoRov Extractable & Magnetic Bread Lame Dough Scoring Tool

Sourdough Starter Kit, Banneton Proofing Basket w Starter Jar, Bread Baking Supplies

Feed starter

Prep cranberries

Mix dries

Mix dries

Autolyse

Autolyse

Autolyse

Add butter salt and starter

Mix

Bulk fermentation (stretch and folds)

Bulk fermentation (stretch and folds)

Bulk fermentation (stretch and folds)

Bulk fermentation (stretch and folds)

Bulk fermentation (stretch and folds)

Bulk fermentation (stretch and folds)

Bulk fermentation (stretch and folds)

Pre-shape

Pre-shape

Final Shape

Final Shape

Final Shape

Overnight (cold) retard

Preheat oven

Score and bake

Score and bake

Score and bake

Score and bake

Score and bake

Put dry rice to prevent bottom from burning

Place in dutch oven and bake

Bake

Remove lid

Cool

Cool

Enjoy

Enjoy

Enjoy

Enjoy

---

Prompt

Here's how I used ChatGPT to created this "Cran-Raspberry Spindrift Sourdough (with Pistachios)" recipe:

I was feeling very creative with my Cranberry Raspberry Spindrift from Costco. I wanted to make sourdough, of course:

I have cranberry raspberry spindrift. What will happen if I use that instead of water for sourdough bread making?

ChatGPT gave me an answer:

Short version: it won’t ruin the dough, but it won’t behave like water — and it’ll definitely change fermentation, texture, and flavor. If you want the straight, un-nice answer: you can do it, but you need to know what you’re getting into or your dough will get weird fast.

Here’s exactly what happens:

🍞 What Spindrift Does in Sourdough Dough

1. The acidity will speed up fermentation

Cranberry + raspberry juice adds acidity → your dough will ferment faster.This means:

• Your bulk may finish 30–40% sooner

• Dough may soften earlier

• Overproofing becomes easier to hit if you walk away

2. The sugar (even small amounts) boosts browning

Even though Spindrift isn’t sweet like soda, natural fruit sugars:

• Make the crust brown more quickly

• Increase risk of dark bottoms

• Give the loaf a slightly caramel-ish tang

3. The carbonation mostly doesn’t matter

The bubbles will:

• Make your dough feel foamy for ~30 seconds

• Then completely disappearSo carbonation is not a factor in the final bread.

4. The flavor will be subtle but noticeable

You’ll get:

• A slight fruity tang

• Not sweet, just a ghost of berryIt won’t taste like “cran-raspberry bread,” more like an interesting, bright sourdough.

5. Minerals & juice solids change gluten strength

You’ll see:

• Dough may feel softer/stickier

• Gluten strength slightly reduced

• You may need a touch more folds or slightly less hydration

👍 If you want to try it

Make these adjustments:

• Replace up to 50% of the water with Spindrift (100% is fine but more unpredictable)

• Reduce hydration by 2–3% on first attempt

• Shorten bulk fermentation time by 15–25%

• Tent the loaf with foil if browning too fast

🧪 What it will NOT do

• It won’t kill your starter

• It won’t stop the rise

• It won’t make the dough collapse

• It won’t “explode” from carbonation

None of the horror outcomes.

TL;DR

Yes, you can use cranberry raspberry Spindrift in sourdough. Expect faster fermentation, darker crust, softer dough, and a mild fruity tang. If you want a clean, predictable loaf, skip it. If you want to experiment and don’t mind managing the dough a bit more closely, go for it.

If you tell me your usual formula (flour %, hydration, starter %, timing), I can tell you exactly how to slot the Spindrift in without messing up the dough.

I was hoping it would suggest a recipe rather than say I can do it, so I asked:

I want you toake a new recipe for sourdough using the spindrift, for thanksgiving. It should be innovative, new, different, bright. You can consider sugar fruit and spice if you think that would be cool. Think for longer. I want something that works and is unique 

ChatGPT gave me the weirdest formatted recipe ever:

Great—love this. I made a bright, Thanksgiving-ready sourdough recipe built around your cranberry-raspberry Spindrift: fruity, a little spiced, slightly enriched with brown butter finish, and engineered so it actually works (not just a gimmick). I thought through hydration, starter contribution, and how the Spindrift’s acidity/sugars will change timing. Follow the schedule below — there are clear checks so you won’t overproof.

Cran-Raspberry Thanksgiving Sourdough (one 600 g-flour boule)

Profile: lightly enriched, bright berry note, orange + warm spice, chewy open crumb with fruity bits and toasted pecans.Yield: 1 large boule (about 1.2–1.3 kg dough final) — ~8 generous slices.Timing idea: mix day → cold retard overnight (8–14 hr) → bake next day. (Because Spindrift speeds fermentation, bulk is shorter — but the overnight cold proof gives depth and control.)

Formula (baker’s % and grams)

(All percentages are of total flour = 100%. Total flour = 600 g.)

• Total flour — 600 g (100%)

  • (This includes the flour inside your starter.)

• Active sourdough starter (100% hydration) — 90 g (15%) — use a lively starter, fed 4–6 hr before use or at peak.

  • (Contains ~45 g flour + 45 g water.)

• Total hydration (target) — 72% → 432 g liquid total (includes starter water)

  • (We reduce hydration slightly because of Spindrift and fruit.)

• Added liquids (after accounting starter water) — 387 g (432 − 45 g from starter)

  • Of that added liquid:

    • Spindrift (cranberry-raspberry) — 232 g (≈60% of added liquids)(we’ll use a portion to bloom fruit; flavor returned to dough)

    • Plain water — 155 g

• Salt — 12 g (2%)

• Unsalted butter (soft) — 30 g (5%) — folded in (a little enrichment for crumb and flavor)

• Maple syrup — 15 g (2.5%) — gives gentle sweetness and color

• Dried cranberries — 72 g (12%) — briefly soaked in Spindrift

• Toasted pecans — 60 g (10%) — chopped

• Orange zest (finely grated) — 6 g (1%)

• Ground cinnamon — 3 g (0.5%)

• Ground cardamom (or mace) — 1.2 g (0.2%)

• Optional — finishing: browned butter wash — ~10–15 g butter to brush after baking

Notes on measurements

• Starter is 100% hydration (equal flour & water). If your starter is very different, tell me next time and we’ll adjust.

• I rounded grams to sensible amounts; small rounding doesn’t break the formula.

Why these choices (brief)

• 60% Spindrift gives a clear berry brightness without totally destabilizing dough. We kept overall hydration slightly lower (72%) to compensate for fruit solids and Spindrift acidity.

• Soaked dried cranberries + pecans give Thanksgiving familiarity without soggy pockets — soak the fruit in Spindrift, then drain and toss in so the flavor is preserved.

• Maple + orange zest + warm spices complement cranberry/raspberry and make a seasonal but not cloying loaf.

• Browned butter finish adds savory richness (and butter is your preference — no margarine).

Method — step-by-step

Prep (starter & fruit)

1. Feed your starter several hours before baking so it’s active (peak domed, bubbly). Use 90 g of it for this recipe when it’s at peak activity.

2. Bloom fruit: place 72 g dried cranberries in a small bowl, pour 60 g of the Spindrift over them, stir, and let sit 20–40 minutes. Reserve the soaking liquid (it goes into dough; nothing wasted).

Mix & autolyse

3. Combine dry: in your mixing bowl, put 555 g bread flour (that’s 600 total minus 45 g flour in starter), the spices (cinnamon, cardamom), and orange zest.

4. Add liquids for autolyse: add the 155 g plain water + (remaining Spindrift + reserved soak liquid) so total added liquid equals 387 g (remember: 232 g Spindrift total; 60 g already used to soak fruit — include that soaking liquid now). Stir to a shaggy mass until no dry flour remains.

   • Autolyse: 40–60 minutes. (Because of sugar/acidity, don’t autolyse longer than 60 min.)

Mix levain / finish mix

5. After autolyse, add the 90 g active starter, maple syrup 15 g, and salt 12 g. Mix to combine.

6. Add butter: add the 30 g softened butter in small pieces and work it in with folds until incorporated. Dough will be softer and slightly tacky.

Bulk fermentation (folds)

7. Stretch & folds: perform 3–4 sets of coil folds or S&Fs, spaced 30 minutes apart, during the first 2 hours of bulk. Example: fold at 30, 60, 90 (and optionally 120) minutes.

   • After the first fold, incorporate drained cranberries and toasted pecans by folding them into the dough on the second fold (or on a gentle lamination pass). Don’t overwork — you want pockets.

8. Bulk finish: because Spindrift speeds fermentation, expect bulk to take ~2–3 hours at room temp (~22°C / 72°F) — stop when dough is puffy and shows gas, ~20–40% rise, not doubled. Use the poke test: a slow, elastic indentation that springs back slowly is good.

Pre-shape & rest

9. Lightly flour surface. Gently pre-shape into a round, bench rest 20–30 minutes uncovered or lightly covered.

Final shape & cold retard

10. Final shape into a boule, place in a floured banneton seam-side up (or bowl lined with floured towel).

11. Cold retard: cover and place in fridge 8–14 hours. This both controls proof (prevent overproof) and builds flavor despite the Spindrift.

Bake

12. Preheat oven to 250°C / 480°F (with dutch oven inside) for at least 45 minutes.

13. When ready, remove dough from fridge, invert onto parchment, score as desired. Carefully place into preheated dutch oven.

14. Bake covered at 460°F (240°C) for 18 minutes, then uncover and reduce oven to 220°C / 430°F, bake additional 18–25 minutes until deep amber and crust is nicely browned. If bottom browns too quickly, tent foil or lower temp by 10–15°C after 10 minutes uncovered.

15. After removing, brush immediately with 10–15 g browned butter for flavor & sheen. Cool at least 1.5–2 hours before slicing.

Troubleshooting & tips

• Ferments too fast? Shorten bulk earlier and lean on a longer cold retard. Because of Spindrift acidity and sugar, bulk often finishes ~30–40% faster than plain water.

• Dough too slack/sticky? You can reduce added water by 10–20 g next time. Make sure mix-ins are well-drained.

• Dark bottoms? Preheat baking surface well, keep the dutch oven hot, and if necessary lower final bake temp by 10–15°C or tent loaf.

• Want brighter berry flavor? Replace 10–20 g of the plain water with the reserved Spindrift soak (we already included it) or add 1–2 tsp of concentrated berry jam kneaded in at the end.

• No dutch oven? Use a tray of hot water or a disposable pan for steam for first 10–12 minutes.

Serving ideas (Thanksgiving)

• Warm slices spread lightly with browned butter + flaky salt and a sliver of orange zest.

• With sharp cheddar and leftover turkey — the berry brightness plays really well with savory turkey and melty cheese.

• Toasted and topped with soft goat cheese + honey + chopped pecans for a seasonal appetizer.

• Make mini turkey-sandwiches with cranberry relish and arugula — great for leftovers/snacking.

Storage & make-ahead

• Keeps 2–3 days at room temp in a bread bag (best first day).

• Freeze sliced: toast straight from frozen.

• Make the dough in the morning, retard overnight, bake next day for fresh bread at Thanksgiving.

Estimated nutrition (approximate) — per slice (1 of 8)

Calories ≈ 385 kcal | Carbs ≈ 60 g | Protein ≈ 7 g | Fat ≈ 15 g | Fiber ≈ 3 g

Notes: This is an estimate based on ingredients (600 g flour, butter, pecans, dried fruit, maple). Actual values vary by flour brand, exact fruit sugar, and slice size — treat as approximate.

If you want, I can:

• Convert this to two smaller loaves (split formula and adjust proofing times).

• Scale to a different flour total (e.g., 1 kg flour).

• Make a whole-wheat or rye hybrid version for deeper autumnal flavor.

• Or produce a printable recipe card with timeline boxes for the day-of schedule.

Which of those would help you most for Thanksgiving?

So I had to ask for regular formatting:

Can you write a regular recipe format? Like more straightforward that I know actual flour up front 

ChatGPT did it but with weird portions/quantities:

Absolutely — here it is in clean, standard recipe format, no baker’s math, no hidden starter flour, everything listed up front exactly as you’ll use it.

Cran-Raspberry Spindrift Sourdough (Thanksgiving Loaf)

Bright, fruity, spiced, with pecans + dried cranberriesMakes: 1 large boule (1.2–1.3 kg)

Ingredients

Dough

• Bread flour — 555 g

• Active 100% hydration sourdough starter — 90 g

• Cranberry-Raspberry Spindrift — 232 g total

• Water — 155 g

• Maple syrup — 15 g (about 1 tbsp)

• Unsalted butter, softened — 30 g

• Fine sea salt — 12 g

• Orange zest — finely grated from 1 medium orange (about 6 g)

• Ground cinnamon — 3 g (about 1 tsp)

• Ground cardamom or mace — 1.2 g (¼ tsp)

Mix-ins

• Dried cranberries — 72 g

• Toasted pecans, roughly chopped — 60 g

Finish

• Browned butter — 10–15 g, for brushing after baking (optional but excellent)

Instructions

1. Prep the starter & fruit

1. Feed your starter 4–6 hours before mixing so it’s bubbly and at peak.

2. Place dried cranberries in a bowl and pour 60 g of the Spindrift over them.Let sit 20–40 minutes. Drain later but save the soaking liquid.

2. Autolyse (hydrate the flour)

3. In a large bowl, combine:

   • 555 g bread flour

   • 3 g cinnamon

   • 1.2 g cardamom

   • Orange zest

4. Add liquids for autolyse:

   • 155 g water

   • All Spindrift except 60 g used for soaking (use both the remaining Spindrift and the saved soaking liquid so total Spindrift in the dough is 232 g)

5. Mix until shaggy. Cover and rest 40–60 minutes.

3. Add starter, salt, sweetener, butter

6. Add:

   • 90 g active starter

   • 15 g maple syrup

   • 12 g salt

7. Mix until incorporated.

8. Add 30 g softened butter in 2–3 small pieces, squishing and folding until fully absorbed. Dough will become silky.

4. Bulk fermentation

9. Over the next 2 hours, perform 3–4 sets of folds every 30 minutes.

10. Add soaked cranberries and toasted pecans during the second fold (or laminate them in).

11. Continue bulk until dough is puffy, about 20–40% rise, total 2–3 hours depending on temperature. (Spindrift speeds fermentation; don’t wait for a double.)

5. Shape

12. Turn dough onto a lightly floured surface, gently pre-shape into a round. Rest 20–30 minutes.

13. Final shape into a boule and place seam-up into a floured banneton.

6. Cold retard

14. Cover and refrigerate 8–14 hours.

7. Bake

15. Preheat oven to 480°F / 250°C with a Dutch oven inside for at least 45 minutes.

16. Remove dough from fridge, invert onto parchment, score.

17. Bake:

• 18 minutes covered at 460°F / 240°C

• Uncover, reduce to 430°F / 220°C, bake 18–25 minutes until deep amber.

18. Optional but amazing: brush hot loaf with browned butter.

8. Cool

19. Cool at least 1.5–2 hours before slicing (or the crumb will gum).

Serving ideas

• Toasted with browned butter + flaky salt

• Turkey, sharp cheddar, and cranberry relish sandwiches

• Goat cheese + honey on warm slices

• Great on the Thanksgiving table as a bright, aromatic bread

Approx nutrition (1/8 loaf)

≈ 385 kcal | 60 g carbs | 7 g protein | 15 g fat | 3 g fiber

If you want this formatted as a printable recipe card or scaled for two loaves, tell me and I’ll adjust.

So I had to explain:

Can you round up or down so that I use actual amounts? For example, 232g spindrift is a really weird quantity 

ChatGPT gave me "human" amounts (sheesh, passive aggressive AI):

Absolutely — here’s the same recipe cleaned up to use normal, human amounts. I kept the dough behavior stable while rounding everything to quantities you can actually pour, scoop, and measure without micro-precision.

This version still works exactly as intended.

Cran-Raspberry Spindrift Thanksgiving Sourdough (Rounded Version)

Ingredients

Dough

• Bread flour — 560 g

• Active sourdough starter (100% hydration) — 90 g

• Cranberry-Raspberry Spindrift — 240 g (1 cup)

• Water — 150 g (⅔ cup)

• Maple syrup — 15 g (1 tbsp)

• Unsalted butter, softened — 30 g (2 tbsp)

• Fine sea salt — 12 g (2 tsp)

• Orange zest — from 1 medium orange

• Cinnamon — 1 tsp

• Cardamom or mace — ¼ tsp

Mix-ins

• Dried cranberries — ¾ cup (about 70 g)

• Toasted pecans, chopped — ½ cup (about 60 g)

Finish

• Browned butter for brushing — 1 tbsp (optional)

Instructions

1. Prep starter & fruit

1. Feed your starter 4–6 hours ahead so it’s bubbly.

2. Soak dried cranberries in 60 g (¼ cup) Spindrift for 20–40 minutes.

   • Drain and save the liquid.

2. Autolyse

3. In a large bowl, combine:

   • 560 g bread flour

   • Cinnamon, cardamom, orange zest

4. Add:

   • 150 g water

   • All Spindrift EXCEPT the 60 g used for soaking, plus the saved soaking liquid

     • (Total Spindrift going into dough = 240 g)

5. Mix until shaggy. Rest 40–60 minutes.

3. Add starter, salt, butter

6. Add:

   • 90 g starter

   • 12 g salt

   • 15 g maple syrup

7. Mix, then add softened butter and work it in.

4. Bulk fermentation

8. Perform 3–4 folds over the first 2 hours, every 30 minutes.

9. Add cranberries + pecans during the second fold.

10. Total bulk: 2–3 hours until dough is puffy ~20–40%, not doubled.

5. Shape

11. Pre-shape, rest 20–30 minutes.

12. Final shape and place in floured banneton.

6. Cold retard

13. Refrigerate 8–14 hours.

7. Bake

14. Preheat Dutch oven at 480°F for 45 minutes.

15. Score dough and bake:

• 18 minutes covered at 460°F

• 18–25 minutes uncovered at 430°F

16. Brush with browned butter while hot (optional but so good).

8. Cool

17. Cool at least 1.5 hours before slicing.

Why these rounded amounts still work

• 240 g Spindrift is exactly 1 cup — easy and predictable.

• Dropping flour to 560 g keeps hydration balanced with the round numbers.

• Water at 150 g is simple and keeps dough from getting too slack.

• All spices and mix-ins converted to cup/tsp normal measures.

If you want, I can also create:

• A printable version

• A two-loaf version

• A no-nut version

• Or a higher-hydration version if you want more open crumb

Just tell me.

ChatGPT once told me cinnamon is bad for yeast:

I thought cinnamon can change how yeasts behave? 

ChatGPT said it's negligible:

You’re right to question it — cinnamon does affect yeast, but the nuance matters. Here’s the straight answer, without sugarcoating:

✔️ What cinnamon actually does

• High amounts of cinnamon slow fermentation because cinnamon contains cinnamaldehyde, which is antimicrobial.

• It weakens gluten if you add a lot of it.

• This is why cinnamon rolls rely on enriched doughs + high sugar + butter to balance it out.

✔️ Why the amount in your loaf is safe

You’re only using 1 teaspoon for 560 g flour — that is an extremely low percentage, around 0.3% of flour weight.

Effects at this level:

• Yeast is not inhibited meaningfully.

• Fermentation speed is not noticeably slowed.

• Gluten structure remains normal.

• The spice comes through aromatically without interfering with rise.

If you used:

• 1–2 tablespoons = yes, you’d see fermentation slow down big time.

• Filling-level cinnamon (like cinnamon swirl breads) = you’d need a stronger dough or more leavening to compensate.

✔️ Why I included cinnamon at all

• To add a warm holiday backbone without overpowering the fruit brightness.

• At this level, it behaves more like a background aroma than an active ingredient.

✔️ If you’re still worried

I can swap the spice profile to something that gives the same fall vibe but zero yeast impact, like:

• allspice

• mace

• ginger

• nutmeg

• orange zest + a pinch of clove

Want the cinnamon removed? Or want me to bump up the spice blend but keep fermentation perfect?

I still wasn't a fan of how ChatGPT was measuring stuff:

Can you rewrite the recipe and use cups spoons and teaspoons were appropriate instead of weird gram amounts?

ChatGPT changed:

Absolutely — here is the same Thanksgiving Spindrift sourdough, rewritten in normal kitchen measurements (cups, tablespoons, teaspoons). I kept the ratios correct so the dough behaves properly.

This is as “real-world” as sourdough recipes get — no scales needed.

Cran-Raspberry Spindrift Thanksgiving Sourdough (US Volume Version)

Bright, fruity, lightly spiced, pecans + dried cranberries

Makes 1 large loaf

Ingredients

Dough

• 4 ½ cups bread flour

• ½ cup active sourdough starter (100% hydration; about the texture of thick pancake batter)

• 1 cup Cranberry-Raspberry Spindrift

• ⅔ cup water

• 1 tablespoon maple syrup

• 2 tablespoons softened unsalted butter

• 2 teaspoons fine salt

• Zest of 1 medium orange

• 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon

• ¼ teaspoon ground cardamom (or mace)

Mix-ins

• ¾ cup dried cranberries

• ½ cup toasted chopped pecans

Finish

• 1 tablespoon browned butter (optional)

Instructions

1. Prep starter & cranberries

1. Feed your starter 4–6 hours before mixing so it’s bubbly and domed.

2. Place dried cranberries in a small bowl and cover with ¼ cup Spindrift (taken from your 1 cup).Soak 20–40 minutes, then drain and save the liquid.

2. Autolyse

3. In a large bowl, combine:

   • 4 ½ cups bread flour

   • Cinnamon

   • Cardamom

   • Orange zest

4. Add:

   • ⅔ cup water

   • All the Spindrift except the ¼ cup used for soaking, plus the saved soaking liquid→ total Spindrift going into dough = 1 cup

5. Mix until no dry bits remain. Cover and rest 40–60 minutes.

3. Add starter, salt, butter

6. Add:

   • ½ cup active starter

   • 2 teaspoons salt

   • 1 tablespoon maple syrup

7. Mix until combined.

8. Add 2 tablespoons softened butter in small pieces and squish/fold it in until absorbed.

4. Bulk fermentation

9. Over the next 2 hours, perform 3–4 sets of folds every 30 minutes.

10. Add the soaked cranberries and pecans during the second fold.

11. Finish bulk when dough is puffy and risen 20–40% — usually 2–3 hours depending on room temp.(Spindrift speeds fermentation — don’t wait for a double.)

5. Shape

12. Gently pre-shape a round, rest 20–30 minutes.

13. Final shape, place into a floured banneton or towel-lined bowl.

6. Overnight cold proof

14. Cover and refrigerate 8–14 hours.

7. Bake

15. Preheat oven to 480°F with Dutch oven inside for 45 minutes.

16. Invert dough onto parchment, score, place in Dutch oven.

17. Bake:

• 18 minutes covered at 460°F

• 18–25 minutes uncovered at 430°F until deep golden brown

18. Brush hot crust with brown butter if using.

8. Cool

19. Cool at least 1.5–2 hours before slicing.

Notes

• The hydration is balanced so it behaves like a typical moderately hydrated sourdough (not runny).

• The 1 teaspoon cinnamon is low enough not to affect yeast activity.

• The Spindrift adds brightness without making it sweet.

• Overnight cold proof deepens flavor and keeps fermentation in check.

If you want, I can also give you:

• A timeline version (“start at X time, do this at Y time”)

• A print-friendly card

• A no-nut or stronger spice variationJust say the word.

I felt like the flour was excessive so I thought maybe I overpacked the cups:

How many grams are 4 and 4 & 1/2 cups of flour

ChatGPT:

Here are the real, practical weights based on standard bread-flour density:

Bread flour (scooped & leveled): ~130 g per cup

So:

• 4 cups bread flour ≈ 520 g

• 4 ½ cups bread flour ≈ 585 g

If you’re spooning & leveling very lightly, it might come out closer to 120–125 g/cup, but for bread flour the 130 g/cup convention is the most accurate.

If you want the recipe tuned precisely to your preferred flour-per-cup number, tell me how you measure (scooped? spooned? shaken?), and I’ll convert it perfectly.

I then thought about pistachios:

Will pistachios work better than pecan?

ChatGPT liked where I was going with this:

Short answer: Yes — pistachios will work beautifully, and in some ways they’re better than pecans for this loaf.

Here’s the breakdown so you know what’s actually changing:

✔️ Why pistachios work well

• Color: The green pops against the cranberry and raspberry tones — very Thanksgiving-festive.

• Texture: Pistachios stay a little firmer after baking; pecans soften more.

• Flavor pairing: Pistachio + cranberry + orange is a legitimately elite combo.

• Sweetness: Pecans bring a caramel sweetness; pistachios are cleaner and slightly buttery, so the berry flavor stands out more.

✔️ How to use them

• Amount: ½ cup, same as pecans.

• Toasting: Toast very lightly — 5–6 minutes at 325°F. They burn faster than pecans.

• Chop: Coarse chop. Too fine makes them disappear.

✔️ When not to use pistachios

Only if:

• Someone has a nut allergy,

• Or you want a deeper, toasted, caramel note (that’s the pecan territory).

✔️ My recommendation for this recipe specifically

Use pistachios.They match the bright cranberry-raspberry profile better and make the loaf feel more modern and special for Thanksgiving.

If you want, I can rewrite your recipe with a pistachio variation, or give you a version with both nuts for a layered flavor.

I wasn't digging the toasting part:

Do I need to toast them? They are already pretty crunchy

ChatGPT:

You don’t need to toast them if they’re already crunchy — pistachios are one of the few nuts that work great untoasted in sourdough.

But here’s the honest breakdown so you can decide:

✔️ If you don’t toast them

Totally fine.

• The bread will have a fresher, greener pistachio flavor.

• They’ll keep most of their crunch, especially if they’re roasted already.

• The bright berry/Spindrift flavor will come through more clearly.

✔️ If you do toast them lightly

Still optional, but it changes the flavor:

• Toasting brings out a buttery, warm aroma.

• It deepens the flavor a bit, making it slightly more “dessert-like.”

• They can over-brown during the bake if you toast them too much beforehand.

✔️ My honest recommendation for this loaf

Skip toasting unless they taste bland right out of the bag.Most store-bought pistachios are already roasted enough. Additional toasting won’t help and risks losing the bright pistachio flavor that pairs so well with the cranberry-raspberry and orange.

If you want the loaf to feel even more special, I can help you fold in pistachio paste, pistachio sugar topping, or a pistachio crust — but the simple version works perfectly.

I asked for the recipe again:

Write again with pistachio. Use grams for the flour and cups in brackets. Rest as-is. No orange zest . Recipe to adjust below, only change what I asked, do not change the rest

Scroll to the top or click below for the final recipe.

---

Jump to recipe

---

Comments